The Role of India’s Finance Commission.

Balancing Growth and Fairness.

The 16th Finance Commission recently visited Tamil Nadu to understand the state’s unique challenges. Tamil Nadu’s Chief Minister, M.K. Stalin, shared ideas on how to improve the resource-sharing system to benefit both high-performing states like Tamil Nadu and less-developed states. His suggestions aim to make the system fairer and more effective, addressing the diverse needs of all states while ensuring progress for the entire nation.

This can be compared to a classroom where students have different abilities. Some students may need more help, while others excel and move ahead quickly. A teacher must carefully divide resources like time and books to ensure that every student is supported. Similarly, the Finance Commission acts like this teacher for India. It decides how to share the country’s tax money between the central government and the states, and also among the states themselves, to make sure everyone gets what they need.

India is a large and diverse country with states at different levels of development. The Finance Commission ensures that less-developed states receive enough resources to grow, while encouraging high-performing states to continue driving the nation’s economy. This essay explores how the Finance Commission works, the challenges it faces, and ways to make it better.

Understanding How the Finance Commission Works

The Finance Commission has two main responsibilities. It helps divide the tax money collected by the central government. This is done to ensure that both the central government and the states get their fair share. This division of resources is essential for maintaining balance and fairness across the country.

The first duty is vertical devolution. This means deciding how much of the central government’s tax money should go to all the states combined. For example, the 15th Finance Commission suggested that 41% of the taxes collected should be shared with the states. This helps states have enough funds for their development work.

The second duty is horizontal devolution. After the total amount for states is decided, this step distributes it among individual states. The amount a state gets depends on factors like its population, income levels, and how well it collects taxes. Poorer states usually get more money to support their growth and progress.

Both vertical and horizontal devolutions work together to maintain “fiscal federalism.” This term means sharing financial power between the central government and the states so that all parts of the country can grow and succeed together.

Challenges in Resource Distribution

The Finance Commission plays an important role in dividing the country’s tax money fairly, but it also faces many challenges. One of the major issues is related to vertical devolution, which refers to how the central government shares its tax revenue with the states. According to the rules, 41% of the total tax money collected by the central government is supposed to go to the states. However, in reality, only about 33% of this money actually reaches them. This happens because the central government keeps some money through special taxes called cesses and surcharges, which are not shared with the states.

States also face financial pressure because they are responsible for many important tasks like building schools, hospitals, and roads. These are essential for people’s welfare, but states do not have the power to collect as many taxes as the central government. This often leaves them struggling to find enough funds to pay for these projects. Adding to this challenge, states are required to contribute money for centrally sponsored schemes, which are programmes led by the central government. This makes their financial burden even heavier. These combined problems make it difficult for states to manage their responsibilities and carry out the development work that is needed for their people.

Tamil Nadu’s Unique Challenges

To solve the problems faced by states, Tamil Nadu’s Chief Minister, M.K. Stalin, has suggested some changes to improve the way money is shared between the central government and the states. These ideas aim to make the system fairer and more effective for all states, whether they are less developed or high-performing.

One of Stalin’s key proposals is to increase vertical devolution, which is the share of tax revenue states receive. He suggests raising this from 41% to 50%. This would allow states to have more funds to run local programmes without depending too much on money from the central government.

Stalin also proposes changes to horizontal devolution, which divides money among individual states. He believes the system should not only focus on giving more funds to poorer states but also reward high-performing states like Tamil Nadu. This would ensure that less-developed states have enough to meet their basic needs while progressive states can continue to boost the economy.

Another important suggestion is to incentivise performance. States that use their money well and help the country grow should be rewarded. This would encourage all states to improve their financial management and development efforts.

Lastly, Stalin highlights the need to address unique challenges. Special funds should be given to states with aging populations and rapid urbanisation. This would help states like Tamil Nadu avoid the “middle-income trap,” where growth slows before achieving wealth.

By adopting these ideas, the Finance Commission could create a system that benefits all states and supports India’s progress.

Broader Goals of the Finance Commission

The Finance Commission does more than just divide money; it also helps shape India’s future by focusing on important issues. One goal is to promote manufacturing growth by encouraging industries to develop in all regions, which can boost the economy. Another focus is managing urbanisation by helping cities grow in a sustainable way. This includes investing in infrastructure like roads, housing, and public transport. The Finance Commission also works on building climate resilience by allocating funds to protect states from the harmful effects of climate change. These efforts aim to create a stronger and more balanced economy, where every state contributes to and benefits from national progress.

Balancing Fairness and Growth

The Finance Commission faces a tough task: ensuring fairness while fostering growth. Like a teacher who balances attention among all students, it must:

Give less-developed states the support they need to improve.
Empower high-performing states to continue excelling and driving the national economy.

For example, Tamil Nadu’s contributions to manufacturing and urbanisation are essential for India’s overall growth. At the same time, less-developed states must be given the resources to build basic infrastructure like schools and hospitals. By adopting a balanced approach, the Finance Commission can create a “larger national economic pie” where everyone benefits.

Conclusion

The Finance Commission is like a bridge connecting India’s diverse states to its shared future. Its work impacts millions of lives, determining how resources are distributed and how challenges are addressed. M.K. Stalin’s proposals provide valuable insights into making this system more effective, ensuring that every state can contribute to and benefit from India’s progress.

By increasing vertical devolution, balancing horizontal devolution, addressing unique state challenges, and incentivising performance, the Finance Commission can create a system that is both fair and forward-looking. Just as a classroom thrives when every student is supported and encouraged to excel, India will prosper when its fiscal policies promote fairness and growth for all. This is not just about numbers; it is about building a nation where every state plays a vital role in achieving shared success.

Is this helpful ? x

Subscribe to our Youtube Channel for more Valuable Content – TheStudyias

Download the App to Subscribe to our Courses – Thestudyias