Font size:
Print
HIB Visas – Skilled Immigration as a Catalyst for Job Creation
Context:
With the coming in power of Donald Trump there is a rising debate in the USA about the future of HIB Visas policy.
About Skilled Immigrants
- Role of Skilled Immigrants: In hubs like Silicon Valley, Boston, and San Diego, skilled immigrants are not just filling existing roles; they are creating jobs, launching startups, filing patents, and significantly contributing to the broader economy.
- Skilled immigrants play a pivotal role in driving innovation and economic growth, particularly in knowledge-based industries like technology, biotech, and research.
- Impact on native employment: The idea that restricting skilled immigration leads to more jobs for native workers is misleading and counterproductive. Instead of boosting native employment, it often leads to outsourcing of talent and operations to other countries.
Benefits of Providing H-1B Visas and the Harmful Effects of Denying H-1B Visas
- Benefits of H-1B Visas
-
- Job Creation: Research shows that each H-1B visa holder creates 1.83 additional jobs for native-born workers within 7 years.
Debate on H-1B Visas Suppressing Wages
- The notion that H-1B workers suppress wages is unfounded.
- Boosting Native Wages: Studies have shown that the influx of foreign STEM talent actually boosts native wages, particularly in high-tech fields, by increasing productivity and innovation.
- Research demonstrates that for every 10% increase in foreign STEM workers, native wages rise by 0.5% to 0.6%.
- Wage Growth: Median wages for H-1B workers have increased significantly, outpacing wage growth for U.S. workers.
- Economic Growth: Immigrant-founded companies are responsible for a significant share of investment and job creation in the U.S.
- Innovation: Skilled immigrants contribute to the U.S.’s leadership in global technological and scientific innovation.
- Harmful Effects of Denying H-1B Visas
-
- Reduced Talent Pool: Restrictions lead to a shortage of qualified workers in sectors reliant on STEM skills.
- Outsourcing: Firms shift operations and hire talent abroad, leading to the loss of domestic jobs.
- Innovation Slowdown: A reduction in skilled immigration hampers the U.S.’s ability to remain at the cutting edge of global innovation, particularly in tech-driven sectors.
Impact of H-1B Visa Ban on India and the USA
-
Impact on the USA
-
-
- Restricting skilled immigration undermines America’s technological leadership, especially in Silicon Valley and other innovation hubs.
- The flow of foreign talent into the U.S. has contributed to job creation, higher wages, and global competitiveness.
-
-
Impact on India: The Concept of “Brain Circulation”
-
- Indians receive around 70% of H-1B visas, but this is shifting from “brain-drain” to “brain circulation.”
- India benefits from the expertise of its emigrant professionals, who return home with skills and knowledge that enhance India’s tech sector and innovation ecosystem.
- Skilled migration creates a mutually beneficial exchange, with knowledge, capital, and innovation flowing both ways between India and the U.S.
Way Forward on Regulating HI-B Visas
- Nuanced Immigration Policies: A blanket restriction on skilled immigration is counterproductive. Policies should recognise the complementary relationship between foreign talent and domestic job creation.
- Visa Flexibility: Adjust H-1B visa caps to align with market demands, reflecting the actual need for skilled workers.
- Fast-Track Mechanisms: Implement expedited processing for critical skills and entrepreneurs who can generate innovation and job creation.
- Permanent Residency Pathways: Provide pathways to permanent residency for STEM graduates to retain the best talent trained in the U.S.
Steps India Should Take to Transform Its Relationship with Skilled Migration
- Innovation Clusters: India should focus on creating specialised innovation hubs, providing tax incentives, research grants, and infrastructure that meet global standards.
- Setting New Paradigms: Shift from catching up to setting global standards in fields like fintech, AI, and clean energy (e.g., IndiaStack, UPI).
- Supporting Risk-Taking: Cultivate an environment that encourages entrepreneurship and innovation, including startup visa programs and initiatives that attract global talent to India.
How India Can Implement This Policy
- OCI Process Streamlining: Improve Overseas Citizen of India (OCI) processes and establish pension portability agreements to ease the transition for skilled professionals.
- Talent Mobility Systems: Build automated mobility systems to track and manage skilled migration, ensuring efficient matching of talent to opportunities.
- Joint Research Funding: Initiate joint funding for research with international partners, and create avenues for technology transfer to foster collaboration and innovation.
- Shared Patent Applications: Facilitate shared patent applications and cross-border technology agreements to build a stronger global presence.
Conclusion: Talent Mobility is Not a Zero-Sum Game
- The global competition for skilled talent should not be viewed as a zero-sum game, where one nation’s gain is another’s loss.
- Talent mobility fosters a global exchange of knowledge, boosting productivity and innovation across borders.
- India must embrace its role as a dynamic participant in the global talent network, creating a system that benefits both home and host countries by encouraging brain circulation and not merely exporting talent.
