Font size: 18px14px
Print
India’s Services-Led Economy: A Mixed Blessing
Context:
India’s shift towards a services-led economy, highlighted the strong growth in service exports, particularly through Global Capability Centres (GCCs). While this shift has spurred economic progress, it has also created structural imbalances, such as a reliance on low-productivity sectors and rising income inequality.
The Rise of Services Exports:
- Strong Performance Amidst Record Trade Deficit
India’s service exports have shown remarkable growth, even as the trade deficit reached a record high of $37.9 billion in November 2024. Provisional data indicates that service exports could overtake merchandise exports for the first time. - Resilience Against Protectionism and Geopolitical Risks
Unlike goods exports, which are vulnerable to protectionist measures and geopolitical disruptions (e.g., the impact of the Ukraine war), service exports are more insulated. This makes them a safer bet for long-term economic growth.
Global Capability Centres: The New Growth Engine
- From IT to High-End Services: While India’s infotech and IT-enabled services boomed in the past, the focus is now shifting towards Global Capability Centres (GCCs), which provide high-end services at competitive prices.
- India vs. China: A Different Path: Unlike China, which became the “factory to the world” with mass-produced, low-cost goods, India is becoming a provider of high-value services. This distinction is driving India’s emergence as a leader in the global services market, leveraging its skilled talent pool.
The Challenges of Services-Led Growth:
- Fewer Jobs and Higher Skill Requirements: Despite the success of service exports, the sector creates fewer jobs than manufacturing. Service roles demand higher education and skill levels, which limits employment opportunities for low-skilled workers.
- Widening Income Inequality: The shift towards services, which typically offer higher wages, is likely to widen the income gap. While the sector contributes significantly to GDP, the disparity between wages in services and manufacturing could exacerbate social inequality.
- The Labour Market Disconnect:
- Employment Patterns vs. Economic Output: Despite services driving GDP growth, 69% of India’s workforce remains dependent on agriculture and industry, with only 31% employed in services.
- Risk of Social Discontent: The growing disparity between employment in low-productivity sectors and the high value added by services could lead to social unrest if not properly managed. There is a need for more inclusive growth that integrates the broader population into the benefits of a services-led economy.
Structural Transformation: Skipping the Manufacturing Phase
- India’s Unique Economic Journey
India’s economic transformation has defied traditional development models. While other countries moved from agriculture to manufacturing and then to services, India has largely skipped the manufacturing phase. Today, services contribute 55% to India’s GDP, while manufacturing remains stagnant at 17%. - Implications of Skipping Manufacturing
By bypassing the manufacturing phase, India may have accelerated economic growth, but it has also created structural imbalances, especially in terms of employment. The transition directly to a services-driven economy has led to a growing reliance on high-skill jobs while leaving a large portion of the population in agriculture and low-productivity industries.
Way Forward – Addressing the Imbalances:
- Focus on Inclusive Growth and Skill Development
To ensure the sustainability of services-led growth, India must focus on creating opportunities for workers in lower-skill sectors and providing training to help them transition to higher-skill jobs. Expanding education and skill development programs will be crucial to address the widening inequality. - Bridging the Gap Between Employment and Output
India needs to find ways to align its employment patterns with the output of its most productive sectors. Ensuring that workers in agriculture and industry can transition into the services sector, or benefit from its growth in other ways, will be key to maintaining social stability and avoiding discontent. - A Balanced Transformation
While India has made impressive strides as a services-led economy, addressing the structural imbalances, improving skills, and ensuring inclusive growth will be critical for long-term success. Balancing the transition between services, manufacturing, and agriculture will help maintain India’s growth trajectory and avoid social tensions.
