Font size:
Print
Quantum Nature of Gravity
Context:
Scientists have long sought to reconcile general relativity (which explains gravity) with quantum mechanics (which explains the other three fundamental forces). A new study published in Physical Review Letters on October 29, 2024, proposes an experiment to test whether gravity is quantum mechanical.
Key Insights from Quantum Mechanics and General Relativity
- General relativity and quantum mechanics are both successful theories but are incompatible with each other.
- Quantum mechanics allows for bizarre phenomena like superposition (illustrated by Schrödinger’s cat) and entanglement.
- Measurement of a quantum system causes collapse into a definite state, which does not occur in classical physics.
- Scientists seek experiments to determine whether gravity follows quantum mechanical rules or remains classical.
Current Challenges in Uniting Quantum Mechanics and Gravity
- Theories like string theory and loop quantum gravity attempt to bridge the gap but remain untestable due to extreme conditions required.
- Physicists need precise experiments that rule out alternative explanations for gravity’s behaviour.
- Unlike classical Newtonian mechanics, where measurements don’t change a system, quantum mechanics dictates measurements force a system into a definite state.
Proposed Experiment to Test Gravity’s Quantumness
- The new study suggests using a test mass in superposition, interacting gravitationally with a probe mass to force a state collapse.
- Both masses will exist in a superposition of different paths, and their gravitational interaction could reveal if gravity behaves quantum mechanically.
- The test focuses on weak gravitational fields rather than extreme environments like black holes.
Experimental Challenges in Creating Quantum Superposition
- Quantum effects are typically observed at the atomic scale, while gravity is measurable around large objects.
- The difficulty of creating spatial quantum superposition in an object is massive enough to have measurable gravity.
- The proposed experiment involves nanocrystals weighing one-trillionth of a gram with a separation of one-tenth of a millimetre.
- Placing nanocrystals in superposition is one billion times harder than previous quantum experiments with macromolecules.
- Creating the superposition is the main challenge.
Techniques to Achieve Superposition
- Researchers propose using the quantum property of spin, which affects the nanocrystals’ motion and can be manipulated with a magnetic field.
- The spin remains in superposition until measured, affecting the nanocrystal’s path.
Environmental Challenges & Solutions
- Quantum states are extremely fragile and need rapid measurements before they collapse.
- Environmental disturbances like seismic activity and moving clouds could destroy the experiment’s setup.
- The experiment must occur in a near-perfect vacuum with highly efficient measurements.
Hope for the Future
- Despite difficulties, physicists are optimistic as this experiment offers a shorter timeline than testing quantum gravity near black holes.
- Researchers believe that just a few years ago, testing quantum gravity seemed impossible even in theory.
- They remain open-minded, acknowledging that the results may suggest gravity is not strictly quantum or classical but something entirely new.
