Font size:
Print
Towards Meaningful Quad Cooperation on Intelligence
Context:
The Quad (U.S., Japan, India, Australia) has evolved from an informal dialogue to a strategic partnership addressing security challenges in the Indo-Pacific.
- Its expanded agenda now includes climate change, telecommunications, and intelligence sharing, leveraging artificial intelligence to enhance security cooperation.
The Role of AI in Enhancing Quad Intelligence
- AI and National Security:
- Despite inherent risks, collaboration on artificial intelligence offers substantial benefits for improving intelligence functions.
- AI capabilities like automation for sensor data, data analytics for managing large datasets, and machine learning for anomaly detection can significantly enhance the intelligence-gathering process.
- Quad’s Strengths in AI:
- India and Japan bring complementary strengths to the Quad’s AI capabilities:
- India contributes its talent pool in AI development.
- Japan adds computing power, making the collaboration highly effective in building advanced intelligence systems.
- AI Tools: Many AI tools used in intelligence operations are sourced from startups like CuttingEdgeAI (US) and 114ai (India), demonstrating the vital role of private sector innovation.
- Security Considerations: Collaborating on AI tools and business processes does not necessarily require compromising sensitive intelligence sources or methods.
- India and Japan bring complementary strengths to the Quad’s AI capabilities:
- Co-development of AI Tools:
- Collaborative development of AI systems among Quad members can lead to:
- Individual Improvement: Each member state’s intelligence infrastructure can be enhanced for strategic competition, especially against China.
- Common Standards: Establishment of interoperable systems, leading to more efficient and effective intelligence cooperation among Quad countries.
- Collaborative development of AI systems among Quad members can lead to:
- AI Applications in Quad Initiatives:
- Maritime Domain Awareness: The Indo-Pacific Partnership for Maritime Domain Awareness (IPMDA) aims to leverage AI to create a common operating picture (COP) for maritime activities, enhancing security in critical maritime zones.
- Humanitarian Assistance and Disaster Relief: AI-driven tools could streamline intelligence collection, facilitating quicker, more predictive responses during humanitarian crises and disaster relief operations.
Reasons for Enhancing Intelligence sharing in QUAD: Emerging Security Challenges
- Piracy in the Indian Ocean Region (IOR) is escalating, threatening global trade and maritime security.
- Undersea Domain Security: China’s actions, including damaging submarine cables, have raised concerns over the security of undersea domains, necessitating increased focus on undersea domain awareness (UDA).
- India’s Role: India’s Information Fusion Centre (IFC-IOR) plays a crucial role in facilitating intelligence sharing for counter-piracy efforts and collaborative security initiatives with Quad partners.
Challenges in Intelligence Cooperation: Internal and External Dynamics
- US-China Tech Rivalry:
- The intensifying U.S.-China technological rivalry, particularly in artificial intelligence (AI), could impede multilateral intelligence sharing in emerging technologies, complicating cooperation within the Critical and Emerging Technologies Working Group.
- U.S. prioritisation of national tech development may hinder broader Quad initiatives, affecting collaboration on AI and other critical technologies.
- National Counterintelligence Efforts:
- Quad countries are enhancing counterintelligence frameworks to safeguard the security of shared intelligence.
- Japan has recently enacted legislation to address espionage risks, while India’s Multi-Agency Centre (MAC) is expanding its role in ensuring interoperability and controlling external intelligence flows.
- Australia’s Commitment: Australia emphasises anti-compromise measures to protect its strategic programs, particularly under the AUKUS framework.
- Intelligence Sharing Challenges:
- Sharing intelligence among Quad members is fraught with challenges due to concerns over secrecy and counterintelligence risks.
- Five Eyes Alliance: The U.S. and Australia benefit from pre-existing intelligence-sharing mechanisms through the Five Eyes alliance, but India, a relatively new partner in this realm, faces difficulties in establishing trusted systems for such exchanges.
