Redefining Masculinity: A Pathway to Ending Violence Against Women in India and Beyond
Introduction – Redefining Masculinity
Violence against women is a pressing global issue that affects millions, cutting across cultures, socioeconomic statuses, and geographic boundaries. The World Health Organisation estimates that one in three women worldwide experience physical or sexual violence during their lifetime, often perpetrated by intimate partners. While policies and laws have made strides in addressing these issues, a critical root cause remains largely unchallenged: the societal construction of masculinity. Traditional notions of masculinity often glorify dominance, aggression, and emotional suppression, creating conditions that normalise violence and inequality.
India, a country with deeply entrenched patriarchal values, exemplifies the intersection of traditional masculinity and gender-based violence. Yet, amidst these challenges, there are sparks of hope. Programmes like MASVAW (Men’s Action to Stop Violence Against Women) and UNESCO’s Transforming MENtalities initiative demonstrate that engaging men in redefining masculinity can transform societal norms and reduce violence against women. This essay critically dwells on the importance of redefining masculinity in India and globally, exploring its roots, impact, and potential as a pathway to gender equity.
Understanding Masculinity: Its Construction and Consequences
Masculinity is not an inherent quality but a social construct shaped by cultural norms, traditions, and historical contexts. In its traditional form, often referred to as “hegemonic masculinity,” it promotes attributes such as physical strength, dominance, control, and emotional stoicism. While these traits are celebrated, they often marginalise other expressions of masculinity that are more collaborative, empathetic, or nurturing.
Globally, hegemonic masculinity has fostered environments where men are conditioned to equate power with control, often through violence. Studies indicate a strong correlation between adherence to traditional masculine norms and violent behaviour towards women. For example, a meta-analysis revealed that traditional masculinity ideology strongly predicts both attitudes that justify violence and violent behaviours. In South Africa, traditional masculinity has been linked to widespread intimate partner violence, exacerbated by racial and economic inequalities.
In India, the situation is equally complex. Patriarchal structures dictate rigid gender roles that subordinate women and reinforce male authority. This manifests in high rates of domestic violence, honour killings, and other forms of gender-based violence. The National Family Health Survey (NFHS) highlights that nearly 30% of Indian women have experienced domestic violence, a figure likely underreported due to stigma and fear. These statistics are not isolated incidents but symptoms of a broader cultural framework that normalises male dominance and suppresses gender equity.
Masculinity and Violence Against Women in India
India presents a unique landscape where traditional notions of masculinity are interwoven with cultural, religious, and economic factors. From an early age, boys are conditioned to see themselves as providers and protectors, while girls are taught to be submissive and accommodating. This socialisation reinforces toxic behaviours, including entitlement over women’s bodies and lives.
One stark example is the phenomenon of dowry violence, where women are abused, and sometimes killed, for not meeting dowry demands. Such practices stem from deeply rooted beliefs about male control over resources and decision-making. Honour-based violence further reflects the interplay of masculinity and cultural expectations, as men often resort to violence to “restore family honour” when women defy traditional norms.
At the same time, societal structures rarely challenge these harmful norms. Men who exhibit aggression are often valorised, while those who express vulnerability are stigmatised. Such dynamics not only harm women but also perpetuate cycles of emotional repression and toxic behaviour among men, trapping them in rigid roles that stifle their humanity.
The Role of Interventions in Redefining Masculinity
Despite these entrenched norms, initiatives in India and beyond have begun to challenge the status quo by engaging men as active participants in gender equality. These interventions aim to dismantle toxic masculinity and promote healthier, more inclusive ideals.
- The MASVAW Initiative
Men’s Action to Stop Violence Against Women (MASVAW) exemplifies grassroots activism aimed at redefining masculinity in India. Launched in Uttar Pradesh, this initiative mobilises men to reflect on their attitudes and behaviours towards women. Through workshops, peer discussions, and community events, MASVAW activists challenge patriarchal norms and encourage men to adopt equitable practices in their personal and professional lives.
What sets MASVAW apart is its emphasis on relational change. Activists engage with their families, friends, and colleagues, creating a ripple effect that fosters broader societal transformation. A study of MASVAW participants found significant shifts in gender attitudes, with men reporting greater involvement in household chores and shared decision-making.
- Gender Equity Movement in Schools (GEMS)
The GEMS programme targets adolescents, fostering discussions on gender equity in Indian schools. By integrating activities like role-playing and storytelling, GEMS helps boys and girls understand the impact of traditional gender roles and encourages them to envision a more inclusive future. One student remarked, “I used to believe that only women should cook. Now I think everyone should help at home.” Such moments illustrate the transformative power of early education in reshaping gender norms.
- UNESCO’s Transforming MENtalities
On a global scale, UNESCO’s initiative promotes critical dialogue on masculinity through media campaigns, educational tools, and research collaborations. This programme emphasises the importance of dismantling stereotypes and fostering positive masculinities that value empathy, care, and equality.
Global Perspectives on Masculinity
The challenges posed by hegemonic masculinity are not unique to India. Around the world, programmes have demonstrated the potential of engaging men in gender equity. In South Africa, for instance, intervention programmes have shown that addressing intersectional issues like race and class alongside gender can amplify the impact of anti-violence initiatives. Similarly, campaigns in Scandinavian countries have normalised paternity leave, challenging the notion that caregiving is solely a woman’s responsibility.
The success of such programmes lies in their ability to humanise men while holding them accountable. They recognise that men are not inherently violent but are shaped by societal pressures that demand domination and control. By offering alternative models of masculinity, these initiatives create pathways for men to embrace vulnerability, empathy, and collaboration.
Strategies for Transforming Masculinity
To redefine masculinity and mitigate violence against women, multi-faceted strategies are essential. These include:
- Comprehensive Education
Education is the cornerstone of change. Incorporating gender sensitivity training into school curricula can help dismantle stereotypes early on. Interactive methods, like those employed by GEMS, ensure that lessons resonate with young minds.
- Community Engagement
Localised interventions are crucial for addressing cultural nuances. Programmes like MASVAW highlight the importance of peer-led initiatives that engage men in meaningful conversations about their roles and responsibilities.
- Role Modelling
Public figures play a pivotal role in reshaping societal attitudes. When prominent personalities challenge toxic norms—such as Indian cricketers advocating for shared parenting—they set powerful examples that inspire broader change.
- Policy Reform
Legal frameworks must support efforts to redefine masculinity. Policies that promote shared parental leave, enforce stricter penalties for gender-based violence, and provide funding for anti-violence programmes are critical.
- Intersectional Approaches
Addressing the interplay of gender with race, class, and other identities ensures that interventions are inclusive and effective. Recognising the unique challenges faced by marginalised communities amplifies the impact of these efforts.
Challenges to Redefining Masculinity
Transforming masculinity is not without obstacles. Deep-seated cultural beliefs, resistance from traditionalist groups, and limited resources often hinder progress. Furthermore, societal expectations place significant pressure on men to conform to rigid roles, creating internal conflicts that can impede change.
However, these challenges also underscore the need for sustained efforts. By fostering dialogues, leveraging media, and collaborating across sectors, it is possible to create environments where redefined masculinities can thrive.
Conclusion
Redefining masculinity is not a mere aspiration; it is an urgent necessity for achieving gender equality and ending violence against women. Programmes like MASVAW and GEMS in India, alongside global initiatives, demonstrate that transformative change is possible when men are engaged as allies rather than adversaries. By challenging harmful norms and promoting inclusive values, we can pave the way for a more equitable world. As societies work toward this goal, the redefinition of masculinity must remain central to the discourse, ensuring a future where men and women thrive as equals.
Subscribe to our Youtube Channel for more Valuable Content – TheStudyias
Download the App to Subscribe to our Courses – Thestudyias
The Source’s Authority and Ownership of the Article is Claimed By THE STUDY IAS BY MANIKANT SINGH
