OTT services regulated under Telecommunication Act
Context:
A conflict has emerged between telecom service providers and OTT platform companies over the interpretation of what constitutes a telecommunication service under India’s new Telecommunication Act, 2023.
More in News:
- Telecom operators, represented by the Cellular Operators Association of India (COAI), argue that over-the-top (OTT) communication platforms like WhatsApp and Google Meet should be classified as access services and therefore fall under the new Telecommunication Act 2023 jurisdiction.
- This would require these platforms to be subject to a licensing framework similar to that of telecom firms.
- However, government officials have previously disputed this interpretation, and tech companies are resisting the push for such regulation.
Constitutional Implications:
Arguments For Including OTT in the Telecom Act:
- Level Playing Field: Telecom operators argue that OTT services like WhatsApp provide similar communication services (calling and messaging) without facing the same regulatory burdens, such as licensing fees and infrastructure costs.
- This creates an unfair competitive advantage, and the principle of “same service, same rule” should apply to ensure fairness.
- Revenue and Investment: Telecom operators invest heavily in network infrastructure and spectrum, which OTT providers do not.
- Including OTTs in the regulatory framework could ensure they contribute to the Universal Service Obligation Fund (USOF) and help offset these costs.
- National Security and Lawful Interception: Regulating OTT services is seen as necessary for national security, allowing for lawful interception and monitoring by security agencies to prevent misinformation and criminal activities.
Arguments Against Including OTT in the Telecom Act:
- Technological and Operational Differences: OTT services operate at the application layer, while telecom service providers (TSPs) operate at the network layer, making it unjustified to apply the same licensing framework.
- OTT providers do not own network infrastructure, unlike TSPs.
- Impact on Innovation and Growth: Regulating OTTs could stifle innovation and hinder their growth, especially since they are still developing in India.
- Over-regulation could slow down the dynamic and rapidly evolving OTT market, which is crucial for digital economy growth.
- Digital Rights and Privacy Concerns: Regulating OTTs, especially encrypted services like WhatsApp, to allow lawful interception could raise privacy concerns and infringe on digital rights, making it technologically challenging to implement.
OTT Communication Service Providers vs. Access Service Providers
|
Universal Service Obligation Fund (USOF)
|
