Font size:
Print
India’s Economic Credibility Challenge
Context:
Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman expressed surprise at the low levels of domestic and foreign investment in India, despite tax breaks and strong growth figures.
More on News:
- Private equity analyses have long hinted at “green shoots” in investment, yet actual growth remains limited, raising concerns over India’s investment climate.
- The government often attributes economic challenges to communication issues or frames them as moral imperatives, rather than adopting a critical self-reflective stance.
Morality Play in Economic Analysis:
- Economic narratives often include calls for investment despite demand issues.
- For example, the RBI’s October 2024 Bulletin suggested companies should invest now to avoid losing competitiveness, despite weak demand and low capex.
- The approach has been dubbed “Open Mouth Operations,” wherein mere statements or encouragement are expected to drive economic actions.
Four Credibility Gaps Impacting Investor Confidence:
- Epistemic Gap: Overestimation of middle-class size has dampened demand projections.
- Conflicting data, such as consumer confidence surveys with opposing conclusions, adds to uncertainty.
- Regulatory Gap: India’s “Ease of Doing Business” claim contrasts with foreign analyses, which highlight regulatory complexity and unpredictability.
- GST and other reforms have inadvertently increased regulatory burdens, and corruption has reportedly risen, undermining investor trust.
- Concentration of Capital: Economic policies have reportedly favoured larger enterprises over small businesses, increasing capital concentration in a few top firms.
- This concentration could stifle competition, with firms like Tata, Ambani, and Adani perceived to wield outsized influence.
- Governance Gap: India’s infrastructural improvements (e.g., highways) are offset by basic governance issues like waterlogging in cities, undermining overall credibility.
Loss of Credibility Through Fragmented Success:
- While India showcases select achievements, these are insufficient to establish credibility.
- Effective governance, regulatory stability, and balanced economic structures are essential for building a consistent national reputation.
In summary, India’s economic credibility suffers from gaps in demand perception, regulatory complexity, capital concentration, and governance inconsistencies, leading to what critics call “Open Mouth Operations,” where mere words are expected to inspire confidence and action.
